Beauty Doesn't Fit in the Eye of the Beholder

Is beauty just in the eye of the beholder or does it have universal elements? Is our appreciation of it just an evolutionary trait, or does our attraction to it point to our desire for something divine?
In my search for beauty I stumbled upon "A Darwinian theory of beauty", a presentation by the late Denis Dutton (1944-2010), who was a famous aesthetics professor at the University of Canterbury in Christchurch, New Zealand. He argues that beauty is merely nature's way of acting at a distance.
Dutton believed beauty has universal elements, and I agree. But I cannot accept his theory that beauty is just a trick of evolution. And I am not convinced that hand axes were invented by homo erectus as a form of art. As Dutton states, the general consensus on beauty among those who study it is that it is an evolutionary trait born out of our preference for things that helped us survive, over things that would harm us. Then later, men used beauty to attract mates.
In other words, according to Darwinian aesthetics, beauty is what we evolved to appreciate because of its effectiveness. We learned to appreciate enclosed spaces more than excessive open space in our settlements because the enclosed space offered a level of protection from predators and enemies. We learned to love curves and round objects because they connote fertility---such as a ripe fruit or the fertile land between the curve of a river.
Dutton argues that we favor beautiful things because they are conducive to our survival; we are attracted to lush valleys, climbable trees and tall-grass meadows because they helped us survive in otherwise harsh primitive environments. But I think our love of beauty has the potency to defy this superficial theory. Reducing our love of beauty to a survival mechanism is like putting diamonds in a paper bag.
Our appreciation of beauty comes from God and is a part of our immortal souls. Our love and imitations of beauty are expressions of our longing for hiraeth: the home we lost and can only find through the bits and pieces of it scattered throughout the world. The heart tug we feel when we experience beauty comes from our yearning for the home we cannot completely find here on earth, but we see vestiges of it every now and then---because it is both everywhere and nowhere.
The term "hiraeth" has been mostly forgotten, but it belongs to the family of similar words such as hearth and even heart. We can even trace the connection to the euphemism, "home is where the heart is". Like hiraeth, beauty strikes us with intimacy and familiarity the moment we see it, but it always seems to flee somewhere beyond our reach before we could completely catch it. Beauty has remnants of a distant past in it, but also offers visions of a better future. It is timeless because it gives us glimpses of our eternal home.
Physical beauty can fade in a person, place, or thing, but only because the beauty they had never belonged to that person, place or thing. It fades from one place, thing, or person and passes on to something else; but beauty itself never dies. It flees to find something more alive. It flees to our distant home somewhere unknown and challenges us to follow it there. In so many ways, beauty is a homing beacon from God, if not God himself.
Consider, for instance, an artist's desire to inconvenience himself in order to give humanity something beautiful. This desire is actually a hindrance to his well being. His pursuit of this desire doesn't pay much, and at times it only brings criticism. This is true for whatever passion we pursue. A writer's love of writing is often not met with any helpful compensation. He pursues the beauty of the art out of love of writing itself, not for anything he receives in return.
A person's love for his beloved is the same way. In fact, a person's love for someone else is so different from the common academic understanding of beauty that it is almost the complete opposite. Love is universally and naturally beautiful. This is why we consider love stories to be beautiful. Yet, a person's desire to love selflessly often makes him want to sacrifice and seek discomfort for the beloved, if only to prove his love. In this way, he does desire a kind of beauty, but not the kind that comes from a desire for self-preservation.
One can argue that this sacrificial love still favors the human race overall. After all, in the end, the sacrifices of a mother for her child results in the survival of the younger offspring. But the love I speak of does not always act so rationally, and mere survival falls apart as a motivator on a large scale. A civilization of artists and writers would fail to sustain itself, but as it falls it would pass on things that are more important than itself. This is why we admire and study fallen civilizations: they didn't survive at all, but they gave humanity true, good, and beautiful things and ideas.
One may say that the ultimate goal was still to help humanity survive, though. But that is a poor assessment of the things and ideas they passed on to us. They're constantly pointing to principles and transcendentals beyond this world, even beyond the reality we know. They point to universals we cannot see, concepts that have no substance, yet they speak of them as if we can touch them. This is not the behavior of a species telling future generations what berries not to eat because they're poisonous. It's more like the behavior of a family members giving us memories of someone we never met.
The mystery of beauty can't be broken down by evolution. Nor can it be reduced to personal preferences. Beauty is caught up in the perpetual battle between the head and the heart. Or, to put it as succinctly as Fyodor Dostoevsky did:
The awful thing is that beauty is mysterious as well as terrible. God and the devil are fighting there and the battlefield is the heart of man.
Academia wants to stamp everything with Darwinism. It's no wonder even beauty has fallen prey to relativism. If beauty is just a matter of preference, our opinions regarding it can indeed be corrupted by cultural conditioning, because---unlike beauty---human nature is corruptible. All we need to do is favor fame, fortune, and innovation more than beauty, and we will get people to prefer things that are not beautiful over things that are. To state the obvious, this is what has happened in our culture.
But the truth is, when something is beautiful, there is a truthfulness to its dimensions. It has distinct, recognizable qualities. This allows us to refine our attempts to capture beauty into something better each time, each generation. There is a universal form to beauty that relates to what is true, real, and right. Beauty imitates God's creation. It is a reflection of what already is. This makes it intelligible and relatable. However, beauty also challenges common trends and invites us to reach outside ourselves.
From various sources and my own observation, I have noticed the following elements of beauty:
Wholeness
Harmony
Resonance
Fractal patterns
Ornamental imitations of nature (e.g. cornices and lionheads)
Moderate complexity
Organized chaos (e.g. a busy pedestrian street)
Curves (e.g. arches and domes)
Imitations of nature
Nature itself
For the last element on the list, it is important to note that gardens, flora and trees are not enough to make something beautiful. Modern architects often use landscaping as a superficial way to hide or compensate for the otherwise ugly buildings in an environment---putting the proverbial lipstick on a pig.
Beauty is wired into our conscience and subconscious because it works. It is functional, so favoring function over beauty is not only unnecessary; it is detrimental because beauty always serves a practical purpose, whether we perceive it or not, because truth and beauty are intrinsically intertwined.
For instance, the ornate stonework on a building's facade mitigated the effects of the elements---such as water, mold, and mildew---on the building. We took this concept from nature. If you look at any rock face, you will see it is uneven with various bumps and crevices. Rocks have stood the test of time, so it makes sense for us to emulate their features when building structures we want to last.

Beauty also shows that we are self-conscious, sentient beings who are not only aware of our surroundings, but are able to imitate them as well. Look at the curves, floral and fractal patterns, earth tones, and ornate designs on the facade of a traditional building, and compare these features to the similar shapes you see in a natural landscape: hills, plants, flowers, riverbends.

Beautiful architecture is designed to exist in a symbiotic relationship with its natural environment. Now contrast that with the the rigid, sharp-edged, basic shapes, and greyscale or pastel colors of modern architecture. We rarely see these basic shapes or colors in nature, so the modern structures that are shaped that way stand out like a sore thumb.
Due to our soulless environment, we are starving for beauty. Subsequently, we look for quick fixes to satisfy the need.
Beauty can't be calculated, and for that reason we think it can't be objective. That's why, as Jordan Peterson argues, when speaking of beauty perhaps "transcendent" is a better word to use than "objective".
Our art and architecture is a reflection of the ideas already prevalent in our society. They reveal our heart. Today, they reveal the soulless Darwinian worldview behind even our concept of beauty. Our culture is in a battle for meaning. Darwinism aims to cancel the inherent meaning in all things. "Where your treasure is, there your heart will be also" (Matthew 6:21, Luke 12:34).




Comments